« Khomeinism: Essays on the Islamic Republic | Birds Without Wings »
Banker to the Poor
![]() |
Banker to the Poor: Micro-Lending and the Battle Against World Poverty |
This book is a good layperson introduction to the concept of microcredit and its Nobel Prize-winning champion, Muhammad Yunus. Unfortunately for me, it didn't get into the nuts and bolts of the Grameen microcredit model and why it produces inconsistent results when applied to different regions. However, that level of detail is probably not interesting to most readers, which is why Banker to the Poor is a little bit saccharine at times. Most of the chapters are anecdotes about saintly bank workers, poor but plucky Bangladeshi peasants and above all, Yunus's tireless networking and wasta-mongering with senior government officials.
Regardless, Yunus makes a number of salient points about poverty and the failure of conventional aid programs. First, he acknowledges the existence of an aid "industry" that fails to target the poorest of the poor. This group will largely not benefit from World Bank-sponsored infrastructure projects often touted as growth promoters in developing countries.
Second, he observed that banks don't see much benefit to offering microloans to illiterate rural folk with no collateral. Yunus, who believes that credit is essentially a human right, calls this flagrant financial apartheid. In contrast, his microcredit models (Grameen and Grameen II) are extremely simple to administer and use peer pressure and trust to maintain a high payback rate.
Third, Grameen has made considerable effort to grant 50% of its loans to women. In rural Bangladesh, purdah and other restrictive customs are quite common. This makes it exceedingly difficult to even speak to rural Bangladeshi women, much less convince them to get bank loans. I found it interesting that purdah was strictly enforced but usury (which is frowned upon in Islam) seemed to be widespread, based on Yunus's accounts of corrupt moneylenders and wholesalers.
Fourth, Yunus made an interesting case for corporations operating with a social conscience. Grameen Bank spawned a number of sister enterprises for textiles, energy, technology, education and even a market-leading mobile phone company. Some of these sectors strike me as traditional government domains in Western countries. Reading about these companies (and Grameen Bank's insurance and healthcare programs) gave me the impression that the organization was almost a parallel government in Bangladesh, but market-driven and not strangled by bureaucracy and corruption (or perhaps it is bureaucratic and corrupt, but simply more effective at delivering services to Bangladeshi citizens).
Finally, Yunus commented on the viability of his model for developed countries. He described visiting with some poor Americans with no access to credit, and their enthusiasm at the idea of small loans for home-based businesses. The problem I see here is that most of these tiny operations would be unregistered and illegal. In developing countries where black market businesses, bribery and inefficient tax collection are the norm, escaping notice would be easy. In developed countries, running an illegal business would be much riskier. Yunus acknowledges this problem, and also criticizes the social welfare system for decreasing (and penalizing) entrepreneurial spirit among poor people, resulting in institutionalized, generational poverty.
Overall, Banker to the Poor is a quick, provocative read. Good for cynics and idealists alike.
Posted by eerie at July 9, 2007 04:43 PM
Filed Under: Economics
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.aqoul.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/3369
Comments
Sounds pretty interesting. But when you say "layperson", does that mean that it is useful to read for someone who doesn't grasp economists' lingo at all -- and especially not in English? Like, you know, me.
Posted by: alle at July 11, 2007 05:57 AM
I don't recall any econ jargon, should be pretty easy for you to follow.
Posted by: eerie at July 11, 2007 10:23 AM
Ah, micro credit as salvation.
Utter rubbish, but an easy feel good sell.
Posted by: The Lounsbury at July 14, 2007 10:39 AM
I think the book is supposed to make you smack your forehead and say, "If only I'd KNOWN that micro credit would solve everything!!"
Posted by: eerie at July 16, 2007 01:11 PM
Time to follow up:
Unfortunately for me, it didn't get into the nuts and bolts of the Grameen microcredit model and why it produces inconsistent results when applied to different regions. However, that level of detail is probably not interesting to most readers...
Unfortunately this is precisely the information that tells you if the idea works. Or is being oversold.
In essence in my experience, micro-credit is useful in really corrupt, non-transparent environments where you are essentially making loan sharking formalized and controlled.
(Oh re loan sharking and purdah, come now, sex pushes buttons whereas money... well it is a bit more ethereal.)
Posted by: The Lounsbury at August 16, 2007 09:59 AM

RSS




