« The Selected Writings of Eqbal Ahmad | The Mystery of Capital »
Imperial Life in the Emerald City
![]() |
Imperial Life in the Emerald City: Inside Iraq's Green Zone |
Imperial Life in the Emerald City is a detailed account of life in the Green Zone after the Iraq invasion. As one might expect from title alone, much of the book is spent describing poor decisionmaking by hilariously incompetent political appointees. However, author Rajiv Chandrasekaran acknowledges that the CPA wasn't entirely staffed by green 20-something Republicans. Experienced post-conflict veterans, while highly competent, were often stymied by bureaucracy, inter-agency squabbling, lack of resources and overly optimistic commitments made by Bremer and the White House.
None of the anecdotes are terribly surprising (most were reported in the news), but it's enlightening to see the events arranged as part of a larger narrative that includes US domestic politics, foreign policy, public perception (Iraq and American), etc. Ties everything together rather nicely.
One particularly interesting chapter focuses on the massive push to privatize state-owned industries and abruptly replace Saddam's socialist model with a free market utopia. Most of the state-owned factories were grossly inefficient, overstaffed (government jobs were essentially guaranteed salaries for life) and unprofitable. Official importers were allowed to use the pre-1991 currency rate (~1 dinar = $3US), and the difference between that and the actual rate (~$1US = 2000 dinars) was covered off by the Ministry of Finance.
Now there are all sorts of problems with selling off assets to foreign investors immediately occupying a country, but the team responsible for assessing the factories and preparing them for sale was grossly unprepared for the scale and difficulty of the task. A road to hell paved with good intentions and unrealistic commitments.
Of course, I've always found intricate bureaucratic nonsense interesting, and Imperial Life is full of it. If only there were footnotes.
Worth reading, particularly if you happen to be a bureaucracy/governance nerd.
Posted by eerie at January 10, 2007 06:41 PM
Filed Under: Iraq
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.aqoul.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/3164
Comments
Ah:
Now there are all sorts of problems with selling off assets to foreign investors immediately occupying a country, but the team responsible for assessing the factories and preparing them for sale was grossly unprepared for the scale and difficulty of the task. A road to hell paved with good intentions and unrealistic commitments.
It brings back awful memories of the pipes project.
So much effort, to get nothing.
I should read this book.
Posted by: The Lounsbury at January 13, 2007 07:56 AM

RSS




